Insurance Agency in Columbus, OH

Insurance Agency in Columbus, OH

Leland Smith Insurance Services – Hickey-Morris Insurance is an independent insurance agency serving Columbus, Ohio, and the surrounding Central Ohio region. We serve individuals, families, farmers, and business owners throughout Columbus, Franklin County, and communities across Ohio.

Key Benefits:

Our Insurance Solutions

Leland Smith Insurance Services provides personal, farm, business, and senior health coverage for clients in Columbus, Ohio.

Why Choose Leland Smith Insurance Services in Columbus, OH?

Our Insurance Partners

About Leland Smith Insurance Services - Columbus, OH

Leland Smith Insurance Services, Inc. is an independent insurance agency founded in 1984 by Principal Agent Randy Myers and headquartered in Van Wert. Hickey-Morris Insurance was established in 1959 by Cletus Hickey. The two agencies completed a merger effective March 1, 2016. The Columbus branch opened in 2020, bringing Hickey-Morris Insurance’s independent agency service to Columbus-area clients.

As an independent agency, we represent multiple carriers rather than a single company. Licensed agents compare coverage and pricing for each client across more than 18 carriers. Coverage available to Columbus clients includes home, auto, life, farm, business, Medicare and senior health, long-term care, flood, renters, and disability insurance, along with specialty lines such as umbrella liability, boat, motorcycle, and antique auto.

We serve clients across six locations under four agency names: Leland Smith Insurance in Van Wert and Antwerp, Shisler Insurance in Paulding, Hickey-Morris Insurance in Delphos and Columbus, and Kulwicki-Hilton Insurance in Convoy. We are also licensed to write insurance in Indiana, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Arizona, Wisconsin, Kentucky, Tennessee, and West Virginia.

Frani Wurst profile picture
Frani Wurst
5 months ago
Always helpful
Di Wurst profile picture
Di Wurst
9 months ago
Brooke was very helpful and professional. Thank you!
Melissa Edelbrock profile picture
Melissa Edelbrock
12 months ago
I’ve been with this insurance agency for many years, & I’ve recently needed to call them several times due to recent banking changes. Despite my crankiness over having to pick up the phone & physically call someone, Brooke, Evan, & Patrick in particular have been so very patient, knowledgeable, & helpful, addressing every single one of my questions/concerns within five minutes or less. I couldn’t be happier with the service that Leland Smith Insurance staff has provided and would highly recommend them to anyone searching for reasonably-priced insurance policies (both homeowners and auto), especially if you’re looking for an agency with a local office!
Nick Lockett profile picture
Nick Lockett
1 year ago
Outstanding Service from Hickey Morris Insurance Agency!

I have had the pleasure of working with Hickey Morris Insurance Agency, and I cannot recommend them highly enough. From the moment I reached out for a quote, their team was incredibly responsive and attentive.

What impressed me most:

Knowledgeable Staff: The agents took the time to explain all my options clearly and helped me find a policy that perfectly suited my needs.

Personalized Service: I felt like more than just a number. They genuinely cared about my situation and worked hard to provide the best coverage.

Overall, my experience with Hickey Morris Insurance Agency has been exceptional. I feel secure knowing I have such a reliable team looking out for me. Highly recommend to anyone in need of insurance!
Joel Pohlman profile picture
Joel Pohlman
3 years ago
Have used Hickey-Morris since moving back. First with Dennis, now with Kyle Strawn. They do great work.
Recently, had a crack in windshield. Kyle took care of entire process. Within 2 hours, All Service Glass called me and had me scheduled for replacement.
Highly recommend!
Matt W. profile picture
Matt W.
3 years ago
I contacted Leland Smith based off of a recommendation that they're known for great customer service and offer competitive rates. Brooke and her team got me all set up with home and auto insurance. They've been nothing but timely, professional and all around awesome! I don't doubt one bit this level of support will continue. I recommend working with Brooke andnher team, they've been notch.
Samantha Shafer profile picture
Samantha Shafer
4 years ago
Kyle was so quick to respond to all my questions and concerns! him and the adjuster were able to get us taken care of so quickly! I can not say enough good things about this insurance company. No hassles. Called them about the damage, an adjuster was out in just a few short hours, and we had a quote within no time! Thank you so much!!! You all went above and beyond. Keep up the great work of taking care of your clients 🙂 I will continue recommending you to everyone I know or see inquiring about insurance!

Schedule a Consultation for Insurance Services

Speak with a licensed Leland Smith agent serving Columbus and Franklin County. Review your current coverage, compare quotes across multiple carriers, or start a new policy. Bring or upload a current declaration page, and an agent will return a side-by-side comparison showing where coverage gaps exist and where premiums can be reduced. There is no fee for the review and no obligation to switch carriers.

WHERE WE SERVE

Oh, IN, MI, PA, AZ, WI, KY, TN, WV

FAQ's

Leland Smith Insurance Services offers home, auto, renters, life, farm, commercial, Medicare, senior health, long-term care, flood, and disability insurance in Columbus, Ohio. Specialty lines include umbrella liability, boat, motorcycle, and antique auto coverage. 

Leland Smith Insurance Services provides term life policies (10, 15, 20, and 30 years), whole life, and permanent life coverage for Columbus and Franklin County residents. Policies are written for income replacement, mortgage protection, final expense planning, and estate preservation. A licensed agent can compare policy options and premium costs across multiple carriers.

Auto insurance in Columbus covers liability, medical payments, collision, and comprehensive protection against theft, weather, vandalism, glass breakage, and animal contact. Optional add-ons include gap insurance, rental reimbursement, and towing and roadside service. 

Yes. Leland Smith Insurance Services writes flood insurance for properties in both high-risk and low-risk flood zones in Columbus and Franklin County. Properties near the Scioto River, Olentangy River, and Big Walnut Creek may fall within FEMA-designated flood zones, but low-risk zone properties remain eligible for coverage. Policies are written through the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) and private flood carriers.

Farm insurance covers the farm residence, barns and outbuildings, equipment, machinery, livestock, stored grain, and farm and personal liability. Optional add-ons include equipment breakdown, chemical drift and overspray, loss of income coverage, peak-season grain coverage, and replacement cost coverage for newer machinery. Leland Smith Insurance writes farm policies for operations across Central Ohio and the broader Northwest Ohio region. 

Call Leland Smith Insurance Services at (614) 600-2449. Bring or upload a current declaration page, and a licensed agent will return a side-by-side quote comparison across more than 18 carriers at no cost and with no obligation to switch.

An independent insurance agency in Columbus represents multiple insurance carriers and compares coverage and pricing across them for each client. A captive agent sells policies from a single company only. Columbus residents working with an independent agency like Leland Smith Insurance can receive competing quotes from more than 18 carriers, rather than being limited to one company's rates and coverage options. 

Get a free quote

The Right Time to Secure Car Insurance for Your New Ride

The Right Time to Secure Car Insurance for Your New Ride

The thrill of owning a new car is unmatched, but practical considerations like car insurance often take a backseat amidst the excitement. However, it’s essential to understand the intricacies of when and how to secure…

Why Coffee Shop Owners/ Roasters Need Commercial Insurance?

Why Coffee Shop Owners/ Roasters Need Commercial Insurance?

In the bustling world of coffee, where the aroma of freshly ground beans mingles with the hum of espresso machines, lies a hidden risk that many proprietors overlook – the need for comprehensive commercial insurance.…

7 Essential Steps to Take When Scaling Your Business

7 Essential Steps to Take When Scaling Your Business

Every entrepreneur dreams of taking their business to new heights, and scaling up is often the path to realizing that dream. However, scaling a business is a considerable feat. It requires careful planning, strategic thinking,…

College Internship Form